LONDON,
February 3, 2006 (IslamOnline.net & News Agencies) – With British media shying away
from further fueling Muslims' fury, British Foreign Secretary Jack Straw
Friday, February 3, called the decision by certain media to reproduce
cartoons of the Prophet Mohammed "insulting",
"insensitive", "disrespectful" and
"wrong".
"There
is freedom of speech, we all respect that," Straw told a press
conference in London with Sudan's visiting foreign minister, reported Agence
France-Presse (AFP).
"But
there is not any obligation to insult or to be gratuitously
inflammatory," he said.
"I
believe that the republication of these cartoons has been insulting, it
has been insensitive, it has been disrespectful and it has been
wrong."
Straw
also praised the British media for showing "considerable
responsibility and sensitivity" in its approach to the issue.
The
British press opted against reprinting the pictures, which first
appeared in a Danish newspaper last September and have prompted
demonstrations by Muslims across the world, particularly after they were
reproduced in many European papers this week.
Responsible
Media
In
editorials, British newspapers debated Friday the conflict between
upholding free speech and the uproar any publication of the cartoons
would cause.
Even
Britain's normally "provocative" newspapers have refused to
publish the cartoons that have outraged the Muslim world, prompting some
commentators to question whether they have become too politically
correct, according to Reuters.
The
best-selling tabloid Sun said it had chosen not to print the
cartoons out of respect for its Muslim readers while other papers said
it was important not to inflame religious tensions in the country.
A
spokesman for the Muslim Council of Britain welcomed the British press'
stance and told Reuters he thought it showed a maturity that was
sometimes lacking in European newspapers.
"Many
Muslims do have complaints about the press here but it is noticeable
that in the last 10 or 15 years (it) has shown a degree of improvement
in the way it covers these kind of issues," he added.
The
left-leaning Guardian newspaper, which printed a Web site address
to the cartoons, said they wanted to give people the choice whether to
look at the pictures or not.
"It
is one thing to assert the right to publish an image of the
prophet," the Guardian wrote in an editorial.
"It
is another thing to put that right to the test, especially when to do so
inevitably causes offence to many Muslims and, even more so, when there
is currently such a powerful need to craft a more inclusive public
culture."
Avoid
Provocation
 |
|
"Freedom of satire which offends the feelings of others, and in this case the feelings of entire peoples, becomes an abuse of power," Silvestrini said.
|
Meanwhile,
an Italian cardinal Friday called on the media to avoid satirizing
sacred Muslim symbols like the "Noble Qur'an, Allah or the
Prophet," saying to do so was an abuse of press freedoms.
"To
be more precise, I would say that one can understand satire on a priest,
but not on God.
"With
reference to Islam, we can understand satire on the habits, customs or
behavior (of Muslims) but not on the Koran, on Allah or on his
Prophet" Muhammad, Cardinal Achille Silvestrini told the daily Corriere
della Sera.
Silvestrini,
82, is a former prefect of the Congregation for Oriental Churches --
Christian churches in the Holy Land which recognize the Vatican.
"Freedom
of satire which offends the feelings of others, and in this case the
feelings of entire peoples, becomes an abuse of power," the
cardinal said.
Asked
by the paper if the Muslim world should learn the principles of
tolerance in Western society, the cardinal said "we too must learn
the experience of others."
He
said one such example was "the cohabitation that Christians and
Muslims have had for centuries in the Middle East."
The
Vatican has made no official comment on the crisis, sparked when a
Danish newspaper published 12 caricatures depicting the prophet.
In
France, Prime Minister Dominique de Villepin said there was a need to
uphold both "freedom" and "respect", while Foreign
Minister Philippe Douste-Blazy voiced "shock" at the
"violence" of some of the Muslim reactions to the sketches.
France
wishes "to avoid anything that is unnecessarily hurtful, especially
in the field of religious beliefs," Villepin told a press
conference in the eastern city of Troyes.
Douste-Blazy,
meanwhile, warned against any further "escalation", in an
interview with French news channel LCI, saying it was "not right to
caricature an entire religion as an extremist -- even terrorist --
movement."
Also
read: